NEWS Students can lead the (Just) Transition on Climate -

From The Dai­ly Cal­i­forn­ian, Tues­day, Octo­ber 8.  Click here to go direct to that link, or here for the Berke­ley­Blog ver­sion.

Vot­ing for a Just Transition


Daniel M Kammen

Screen Shot 2018-10-10 at 4.17.48 PM

Each fall at UC Berke­ley I teach ‘Ener­gy and Soci­ety’, a very unusu­al course that cov­ers the sci­ence, pol­i­tics, and pol­i­cy angles need­ed to under­stand – and to change – our ener­gy sys­tem from one that is now rapid­ly degrad­ing the plan­et, to a sus­tain­able, healthy, and equi­table one.  The best fea­ture of this class is that it is a melt­ing pot not only of dif­fer­ent majors, but also of under­grad­u­ate and grad­u­ate stu­dents work­ing togeth­er to mas­ter the material


The first thing we cov­er, using basic chem­istry that has been well known to sci­ence for over 100 years,is that end­less­ly emit­ting green­house gas­es will warm the plan­et. We have known sci­en­tif­i­cal­ly since the 1990s that cli­mate change is already impact­ing ecosys­tems, crops, and both human and envi­ron­men­tal health.  We have known for almost two decades that we have already warmed the plan­et by one degree Cel­sius, and that at two degrees Cel­sius, dra­mat­ic changes to the earth will be every­day events.


Instead of becom­ing a ral­ly­ing cry for inno­va­tion as were the respons­es to dis­ease (“the war on polio”), food, pover­ty and nutri­tion (“the Green Rev­o­lu­tion”) or the desire to reach space (“the Apol­lo pro­gram”), cli­mate change has become, arguably, the most divi­sive issue in the Unit­ed States.  Where we used to see chal­lenge as an oppor­tu­ni­ty, this one, inex­plic­a­bly has become a proxy-war for eco­nom­ic inse­cu­ri­ty and class division.


After all, the U.S. Envi­ron­men­tal Pro­tec­tion Agency, launched under Repub­li­can Pres­i­dent Nixon and passed through House and Sen­ate Com­mit­tees in 1970.  TheClean Air Actbecame law in 1970, where it passed the Sen­ate with­out a sin­gle ‘no’ vote. Only one rep­re­sen­ta­tive vot­ed against the bill.  Against expec­ta­tions, George H. W. Bush fea­tured the envi­ron­ment promi­nent­ly in his cam­paign, and in 1988 his pres­i­den­cy saw an expan­sive update to the Clean Air Act which the Sen­ate passed with bipar­ti­san support.


Since then, how­ev­er, things have dete­ri­o­rat­ed, with atten­tion and invest­ment in envi­ron­men­tal qual­i­ty at local, to nation­al, and at glob­al lev­els becom­ing the ‘third rail’ of U.S. politics.


This is where local action by Cal stu­dents is so crit­i­cal.  As the acknowl­edged top pub­lic uni­ver­si­ty in the world, Cal stu­dents, staff, fac­ul­ty and alum­ni have helped to make Cal­i­for­nia the remark­able ener­gy and cli­mate leader that it is, but have also found a myr­i­ad of ways to spread those expe­ri­ences across the coun­try and around the world.  That reach has nev­er been more impor­tant than now as we approach the most impor­tant mid-term elec­tion in decades.


At the Cli­mate Action Glob­al Sum­mitin San Fran­cis­co last month I heard an approach that harkened back to the bipar­ti­san­found­ing of the U.S. EPA.. This new vision was stat­ed most clear­ly and elo­quent­ly not by politi­cians, ora­tors, or sci­en­tists, but by high-school and col­lege stu­dents who gath­ered in a series of youth sum­mits orga­nized with­in and around the offi­cial meetings.


What is most iron­ic is that cli­mate change is actu­al­ly one of the most inter­est­ing issues and oppor­tu­ni­ties we as a coun­try have ever faced because its solu­tion cre­ates eco­nom­ic oppor­tu­ni­ties. Every bit of coal, gas, or oil that we replace with ener­gy effi­cien­cy and clean ener­gy is a shift away from min­ing resources to invest­ing in com­pa­nies and invest­ing in peo­ple.  After all, when the fuel is free, cre­at­ing new tech­nolo­gies and build­ing social insti­tu­tions and poli­cies are all ways to invest in our­selves and to both cre­ate employ­ment and to use data and insti­tu­tions to grow the econ­o­my.  My lab­o­ra­to­ry here at UC Berke­ley has been research­ing and doc­u­ment­ing the green jobs ‘div­i­dend’ and has been doing work witha series of stu­dents, many of whom are alum­ni of ‘Ener­gy and Society’.


The clean ener­gy oppor­tu­ni­ty is aligned with core val­ues – at least those stat­ed on paper – by both the Demo­c­ra­t­ic and Repub­li­can par­ties. Instead of one of the few places for bipar­ti­san action, how­ev­er, it has become an area where even the most basic facts are end­less­ly debat­ed.  As research launched at Berke­ley has shown, invest­ments in mass tran­sit and for those who need cars, elec­tric vehi­cles are not only cheap­er to oper­ate than gas-pow­ered cars, but they also lead to dra­mat­ic reduc­tions in urban air pol­lu­tion, a hall­mark of Cal­i­for­nia poli­cies since the 1970s.


As inequal­i­ty has grown across Amer­i­ca, UC-based research has con­tin­ued to high­light the many exam­ples of well-mean­ing poli­cies (such as sub­si­diz­ing elec­tric vehi­cles for the afflu­ent) that exac­er­bate the grow­ing nation­al eco­nom­ic divide.  Instead, efforts launched here to invest in more afford­able homes and apart­ments by inte­grat­ing ener­gy effi­cien­cy, solar, pow­er, and both bet­ter mass-tran­sit and elec­tric vehi­cles for low-income Cal­i­for­ni­ans offers a sus­tain­able path to social equity.


Of par­tic­u­lar note is that California’s land­mark cli­mate leg­is­la­tion, SB32which gov­erns our state decar­boniza­tion from 2020 – 2030, calls for 35% or more, of our green­house gas cap and trade rev­enues (now in the $10 billion/​year range) to be spent on under­served minor­i­ty com­mu­ni­ties. I’ll wager that when we look back this bill, it will be this invest­ment in social jus­tice, not the cli­mate tar­get that will be its most impor­tant legacy.


This is where the Cal stu­dents can play a most imme­di­ate and huge­ly impact­ful nation­wide role: by reach­ing out to fel­low stu­dents, par­ents, and friends both across Cal­i­for­nia and across the coun­try to high­light how dou­bling down on equi­tableclean ener­gy projects offers a rare and gen­uine ‘win-win’ at a time when the coun­try is more divid­ed than ever.


Daniel Kam­men is pro­fes­sor and chair of the Ener­gy and Resources Group, and Pro­fes­sor in the Gold­man School of Pub­lic Pol­i­cy, and in the Depart­ment of Nuclear Engi­neer­ing.  He served in the Oba­ma Admin­is­tra­tion as Sci­ence Envoy for the State Department. 

Twit­ter: @dan_kammen

Browse News

Main Menu

Energy & Resources Group
310 Barrows Hall
University of California
Berkeley, CA 94720-3050
Phone: (510) 642-1640
Fax: (510) 642-1085


  • Open the Main Menu
  • People at RAEL

  • Open the Main Menu